Cherokee Bay Homes with Hartwell Lake

Welcome to Cherokee Bay, a hidden gem nestled in the picturesque landscape of Fair Play, South Carolina, within Oconee County. This charming subdivision offers a unique blend of serene lakefront living and a vibrant community atmosphere, making it an ideal destination for families, retirees, and anyone looking to escape the hustle and bustle of city life.

Cherokee Bay is perfectly positioned along the shimmering shores of Hartwell Lake, providing residents with breathtaking views and easy access to a plethora of water activities. Whether you're an avid fisherman, a boating enthusiast, or simply enjoy leisurely afternoons by the water, this community has something for everyone. Imagine waking up to the gentle lapping of waves and enjoying your morning coffee while soaking in the stunning sunrise over the lake.

The homes in Cherokee Bay are designed with comfort and style in mind, featuring spacious layouts, modern amenities, and outdoor spaces perfect for entertaining or simply unwinding after a long day. Many properties boast private docks, allowing you to fully embrace the lake lifestyle and enjoy countless hours of fun on the water.

Beyond the beauty of the lake, Cherokee Bay is conveniently located near local attractions, shopping, and dining options, ensuring that residents have everything they need within reach. With its friendly neighbors and a strong sense of community, Cherokee Bay is not just a place to live; it’s a place to call home. Come and discover the charm of Cherokee Bay, where the beauty of Hartwell Lake meets the warmth of Southern hospitality!

Newest Cherokee Bay Homes with Hartwell Lake

$360,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

ESCAPE to the LAKE, bring your boat and enjoy the community DOCK with BOAT SLIP included!! CONVENIENCE and EASY ACCESS to I-85 with the BENEFITS of Lake Hartwell while also enjoying the community pool and clubhouse. The TERRACE level offers a private SECOND living space IDEAL for an in-law suite, guests, or a teenager’s retreat complete with its own kitchen, living area, and laundry. ENJOY both an interior entrance and a SEPARATE private exterior entrance for added CONVENIENCE and FLEXIBILITY. START your mornings with a cup of coffee on the WELCOMING front porch, then STEP INSIDE to a warm and INVITING living space. WANDER through and IMAGINE GATHERING here with friends and family in your DREAM kitchen perfect for entertaining! Spacious laundry and mud room leads to the oversized two car garage. RETREAT to your owner’s suite with spacious walk-in closet and ensuite. RELAX on your back deck, ENJOY the large FENCED yard, and UNWIND after a long day. Whether you're looking for your FIRST HOME, a SERENE GETAWAY, or low maintenance RIGHT-SIZING. This property comes with boat parking at the dock, located behind the Clubhouse and Community pool, and offers the lifestyle you've been dreaming of! This PRIME location is easy access to I-85 and scenic Highway 11, close to several local eateries, golf course, Seneca, Anderson, Clemson, Lavonia, Hartwell, and just 45 minutes to Greenville. START LIVING YOUR BEST LIFE! **If Buyer uses preferred Lender, Mary Ripley at Integrity Home Lending, they will receive up to $1800 in paid closing costs at closing.

281 Cherokee Drive, Fair Play

$10,000

Bring your home plan and claim your piece of Lake Hartwell living! This corner lot offers .90 +/- of an acre and is ideal for a home with a walk-out basement. Imagine sipping your coffee on a private back deck as the morning breeze drifts through the trees. Once you're awake, take your loved ones to the community pool or out on the lake—both are within walking distance. Conveniently located off SC Hwy 11 and near I-85, you can be anywhere in the Southeast quickly, though you may never want to leave Oconee County. With three lakes, countless waterfalls, mountain hikes, and all the dining and shopping you need, it offers the perfect balance of relaxation and adventure.

Lot 68 Cherokee Drive, Fair Play

$20,000

Interior lot (30) in Cherokee Bay. .84 acre Cherokee Bay is a small, lakeside development with easy access to Lake Hartwell, and I-85. The neighborhood offers a clubhouse and pool with neighborhood boat slips usually available for $600 per year. Several boat ramps are nearby. The lot lays well for a walkout basement home and there is community water available, so no need to drill well. There is a $1000 lot transfer fee.

00 Bay Drive, Fair Play

$44,900

Discover an unparalleled opportunity to craft your ideal lifestyle within the welcoming Lake Hartwell community of Cherokee Bay. This expansive 0.79-acre lot is perfectly poised for the construction of your dream home, whether you envision a serene weekend retreat or a permanent residence. Nestled along the South Carolina/Georgia border, the location offers exceptional convenience with easy access to the interstate, ensuring seamless travel to nearby Clemson, Walhalla, Seneca, and Westminster. Beyond its prime location, the Cherokee Bay community enriches daily living with exclusive amenities. Residents benefit from direct water access to Lake Hartwell, ideal for aquatic adventures and relaxation. Further enhancing the community experience are a refreshing swimming pool and a well-appointed clubhouse, providing perfect venues for leisure and social gatherings. This property offers a unique blend of natural beauty, community perks, and strategic accessibility, making it an exceptional canvas for your future.

00 Bay Drive, Fair Play

$44,900

Discover an exceptional opportunity to craft your dream retreat within the serene lake community of Cherokee Bay. This generous 1.31-acre lot offers an idyllic setting for either a permanent residence or a tranquil getaway, providing a perfect balance of privacy and community amenities. Residents of Cherokee Bay enjoy exclusive access to a refreshing community pool, a welcoming clubhouse, and convenient water access, perfect for embracing the lakeside lifestyle. The property's strategic location ensures effortless connectivity, positioned just off I-85, near the South Carolina and Georgia border. This prime spot allows for easy commutes and quick access to Lake Hartwell, the vibrant towns of Seneca, Clemson, Walhalla, and Westminster. Embrace the chance to design and build a home in a locale that truly celebrates natural beauty and community spirit, offering a peaceful sanctuary with all the conveniences‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌ nearby.

00 Bay Drive, Fair Play

$66,500

Rare Waterfront Opportunity on Lake Hartwell – 1.95 Buildable Acres in Cherokee Bay! Don’t miss your chance to own two adjacent buildable lots totaling 1.95 acres in the community of Cherokee Bay in Fair Play, SC. These rare waterfront lots only have the Corps of Engineers land between you and the shoreline ensuring serene protected views of Lake Hartwell year-round. Whether you’re a builder seeking a prime investment or a family ready to build your dream lake retreat, this property offers endless potential and the opportunity to enjoy Lake Hartwell's 56,000 acres of pristine waters and its 962 miles of shoreline. Cherokee Bay amenities include a community pool, hot tub, clubhouse, private boat ramp, and dock. While new docks cannot be added to these lots, boat slips may be available to lease which is perfect for lake enthusiasts who want the convenience of direct water access without the hassle of maintenance. Conveniently located just minutes from I-85, you're within easy reach of Anderson, Greenville, and Atlanta while still enjoying the peaceful charm of lakeside living. Whether you envision a full-time home, vacation getaway, or investment build, these lots offer the perfect blend of location, views, and community features. Come see why Cherokee Bay is one of Lake Hartwell’s hidden gems!

Lots 14/15 Bay Drive, Fair Play

$37,000

Create your dream lake lifestyle on this beautiful .92-acre lot in the highly sought-after Cherokee Bay community. Offering scenic water views, this property provides the perfect foundation for your future lake home with easy access to I-85. The Cherokee Bay community boasts a variety of fantastic amenities, including a dock, clubhouse, pool, and well-maintained common areas. Dock slips are available for lease through the HOA, making it easy to enjoy Lake Hartwell's 56,000 acres of pristine waters and its 962 miles of shoreline. Conveniently located just 20 minutes from Anderson, 45 minutes from downtown Greenville, and only 90 minutes from Atlanta, you?ll be close to everything while still enjoying the peaceful serenity of lakeside living. Start building your dream home and make lasting memories on the waters of Lake Hartwell today!

00 Bay Drive, Fair Play

Start Your Search

The Listings data contained on this website comes from various participants of The Multiple Listing Service of Greenville, SC, Inc. Internet Data Exchange. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The properties displayed may not be all the properties available. All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. © 2026 Greater Greenville Association of REALTORS®. All Rights Reserved. Last Updated